Engineering Blog

Building MenuDart and Selling It for a Month

A cat sits at a desk with a wide monitor and laptop as a mouse pointer follows a dart toward a menu

I made MenuDart because the menu bar manager I had been happily using stopped working with macOS 27 GoldenGate. I had been using Ice.

I was already subscribed to ChatGPT Pro when I saw a 50% discount promotion for Claude Code. So I subscribed to Claude Code Ultra (then called Max 20x) and tried building what I wanted.

I use a 40-inch ultrawide monitor, a 14-inch MacBook, and a 16-inch external monitor. I tend to run all sorts of things at once, so I never have enough menu bar space. Changes in GoldenGate meant the old approaches didn’t work well, so I switched to a popup near the mouse pointer. (I heard this may change in 27.2, but I haven’t checked yet.)

What I really wanted was to open a menu bar item’s menu near the pointer, but I couldn’t get that to work. So I decided to show the menu bar items in a popup, open the selected item’s menu, and then move the pointer to it. Moving it plainly seemed a little boring, so I added a dart effect and Coco, my wife’s cat. Of course, everyone has different tastes, so I also added an option to just move the pointer without an effect.

While I was working on the menu bar, I also made app menus available in a popup. On a 40-inch monitor, moving the pointer all the way to a menu can be a bit of a journey.

Once I’d built it, I wondered if someone might buy it as an inexpensive one-time purchase. I buy apps like that from time to time myself, and I thought there might be other people with the same frustrations.

After launch, I wasn’t sure how to promote it. I posted on a site I visit often and gave away 10 free keys. I also offered more keys to people who would test and review it; two people signed up, so I gave away two more. Naturally, perhaps?? Neither sent feedback.

I also used AI agents to send promotional emails to blogs and news sites. I’m Korean, and writing in English doesn’t come easily to me, so I want to be clear that I relied heavily on AI assistance. While sending those emails, I started wondering where there were lots of Mac users. As I looked into those countries, I also expanded the languages I was localizing the app for.

I emailed around 50 places, and about five wrote about the app. I have my own website too, but it gets very little traffic, so it didn’t help much. I had never used Hacker News and had no reputation there, so I couldn’t post. I also posted on GeekNews, a Korean developer site, and it looks like that led to about one sale. There was some traffic from Reddit too, but I didn’t set up tracking from the start, so I don’t know how much it helped.

About 15 copies sold in roughly a month. Around four of those sales happened within a day of the app appearing on a site.

The most memorable experience was with the French-language publication VVMac Le Blog. Bernard Le Du wasn’t particularly enthusiastic at first, but he gave me feedback. When I made changes based on it and let him know, he became more engaged. We exchanged messages several times after that, fixing bugs and changing the design along the way. He was a great help. It felt as though another person had joined the development team.

When he told me he’d published an article, I went to read it and found it professionally written. His other app introductions were good too. As a site specializing in Mac app reviews, it had covered an enormous number of apps. Through his writing, I also found another app that used a popup in a similar way. If I had known it existed, MenuDart’s fate might have been different.

I launched at $6.99 and sold it at a discounted price of $4 through last month. There were 15 paid sales, with VAT charged separately. The discount code only applied when customers clicked purchase in the app, so I issued partial refunds to people who bought directly from the website and missed the discount. One person added it to their cart and then canceled.

There aren’t many customers, and it isn’t a lot of money, but I wanted to add more value for the people who bought it. One frustration I have is that when too many apps are running, the Command-Tab switcher gets crowded. So I added a feature that displays the apps across multiple rows with larger icons. I don’t yet know what else I’ll add.

I’ve also realized how important promotion is. But I still don’t know how to do it.

Myven isn’t selling well, and for now I’m working on a couple of other app ideas at the same time. I wanted to release Blurcept quickly, but there are so many edge cases that I’m still testing it. Before that, I’m thinking of releasing a simple vocabulary app.


This English version was translated with the help of AI.

Join the Investigation

Get the latest updates on my projects and indie hacking journey directly in your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.